Good or Bad for the Jews

"Good or Bad for the Jews"

Many years ago, and for many years, I would travel to Morocco to visit uncles, cousins, and my paternal grandmother. Some lived in Tangiers;...

Tuesday, December 20, 2022

Hanukkah Ain't Christmas or Dewali

This time of year, every year since I was a kid, I get extremely irritated by attempts to make Hanukkah into some sort of Jewish Christmas or Jewish Dewali. 

So tiresome to hear of Hanukkah portrayed, mostly by ultra-liberal Jews, as "the Festival of Lights." Some sort of holiday to spread peace, joy, and cheer to one and all. 


Hanukkah ain't that at all. It's about picking up a sword, and killing the foreign oppressor AND killing those of your own who have sold out to the foreign oppressor. The Maccabees were warriors, not spreaders of love and peace. They rose up against the Seleucid empire, but also mostly against those "Hellenized" Jews, who backed the Seleucid rulers and their attempt to eradicate the Jewish faith. The revolt was a long-shot affair, led by the Maccabee family. The Maccabees, however, eventually defeated the Seleucids, and restored their right to practice the Jewish faith. The Maccabees also proved true to Jewish history in another way: once they became victorious they began fighting among themselves, but that's another story. The Romans eventually moved in, and the rest, well, you know the rest.

Anyhow, we in the West might do with a little more of the original Maccabee spirit as we see our societies colonized from within and without. 

A little less peace and goodwill, and more "This We'll Defend."  

With that said, Merry Christmas to all.   


  1. How about Kwanzaa? (Ducks and runs out of room).


  2. Did not know that, thanks for the History Lesson!

  3. Hanukkah is more "4th of July" than "25th of December".

  4. Interesting how the Maccabees stories seem to go in and out of favor.
    As I understand it, the Books of Maccabees are not part of the Hebrew Bible (correct me if I am wrong) for a number of political reasons.
    The Christian Church decided to include them in the Bible.
    Until Luther, that is, when once again political expediency removed them from the Protestant Bible.
    Seems like nothing ever changes: Cancel Culture is not a modern concept.

    1. The Septuagint (ancient Greek translation of the Old Testament) includes the books of the Maccabees. Since they weren't in the Hebrew canon, Jerome saw Maccabees and other books found in the Greek canon as a lesser, "deuterocanon" or apocrypha. Luther and other Protestants dusted off this idea, but for quite some time continued to print Bibles with the Apocrypha, save in a separate section rather than mixed in with the rest of the Old Testament.

  5. Thanks for history lesson, so keep your sword sharp Dip
    And Merry Christmas to everyone

  6. Merry Christmas to Diplomad, and his readers!

  7. Happy Holidays!



    - reader #1482

  8. My college roommate is Jewish. His wife is Catholic. The first day after Hanukkah is over my family visits his with his mother to have Christmas and eat up their leftover Hanukkah food.

  9. Thanks for the comments. For a more humorous take, try this out:

  10. "This We'll Defend"
    I remember when the US Army said that - not just on its flag - and meant it. Nowadays they have sort out pronouns within first.

  11. Adam Sandler could not be reached for comment…

  12. Wishing you a peaceful and bright holiday.

  13. No doubt these words will soon be redefined and banned into the abyss by our progressive overlords.

    - reader #1482